Burdens of Persuasion and Standards of Proof in Structured Argumentation


Roberta Calegari, Giovanni Sartor

Logic and Argumentation 4th International Conference, CLAR 2021, Hangzhou, China, October 20–22, pages 40-59
Lecture Notes in Computer Science (Lecture Notes in Artificial Intelligence) 13040,  2021
Springer Nature
Pietro Baroni, Christoph Benzmüller, Yὶ N. Wáng (eds.)

In this paper we provide an account of the burden of persuasion, in the context of structured argumentation. First, burdens of proof in legal proceedings are discussed in general, distinguishing the burdens of production and the burdens of persuasion. Then, we focus on burdens of persuasion, illustrating their role in civil and criminal law.
A formal model for the burden of persuasion is then defined, discussed, and used to capture the role of the burden of persuasion in adjudicating conflicts between conflicting arguments and in determining the dialectical status of arguments. We consider how our model can also capture adversarial burdens of proof, namely, those cases in which failure to establish an argument for a proposition burdened with persuasion entails establishing the complementary proposition.
Finally, we examine how burdens of proofs can be integrated with standards of proof defining the extent to which an argument for a proposition burdened with persuasion has to be stronger than arguments to the contrary, in order to meet the burden.

(keywords) Burden of persuasion; Argumentation; Legal reasoning; Standard of proof
 @InProceedings{bp-standardproof-clar2021,
author={Calegari, Roberta and Omicini, Andrea and Sartor, Giovanni},
editor={Baroni, Pietro and Benzmüller, Christoph and Wáng, Yὶ N.},
title={Burdens of Persuasion and Standards of Proof in Structured Argumentation},
booktitle={Logic and Argumentation},
year=2021,
publisher={Springer International Publishing},
address={Cham},
pages={40--59},
doi={10.1007/978-3-030-89391-0_3},
isbn="978-3-030-89391-0"

Talks

Publication

— authors

Roberta Calegari, Giovanni Sartor

— editors

Pietro Baroni, Christoph Benzmüller, Yὶ N. Wáng

— status

published

— sort

paper in proceedings

Venue

— volume

Logic and Argumentation 4th International Conference, CLAR 2021, Hangzhou, China, October 20–22

— series

Lecture Notes in Computer Science

— volume

13040

— pages

40-59

— context

CLAR 2021

— publication date

2021

Identifiers

— DOI

10.1007/978-3-030-89391-0_3

— IRIS

11585/836296

Partita IVA: 01131710376 - Copyright © 2008-2022 APICe@DISI Research Group - PRIVACY